Published Apr 27, 2017
Banana splits, waffle cones are fun, but it's all about the ice cream. Who's got the best?
"We moved here from Seattle, where coffee is a way of life! Sundae's homemade roasted coffee is ridiculously good..."
via Joan W.
"…We moved here from Seattle, where coffee is a way of life! Sundae's homemade roasted coffee is ridiculously good... and averaging about $10.50/lb... …"
"…Awesome! I can buy icecream for me & my 2 kids for the price I'd pay for 1 icecream from one of those more expensive ice cream places - I'm sure you …"
"…The Scoop is by far my favorite ice cream shop in Indiana! The atmosphere is cozy and cute, you can play board games while you enjoy your delicious ic…"
"…I don't believe they have ever been out of my favorite ice cream... No matter when I have gone there..... I also love the fact that they have outside …"
"…There is NO better place to get ice cream!!!!! Handel's is my absolute favorite destination for dessert! No matter where you are, it's worth the driv…"
"…Scoops and treasures is a family owned shop in Whiteland. The Hershey's ice cream is the bomb and the family is so nice and lovely people. While you…"
"…The ice cream!!! Also the staff are great too! Overall a fun atmosphere to hang out, relax & eat ice cream! Whether it be with friends or family, anyo…"
"…Hands Down, some the most innovative, creative, and comfort flavors I have ever tired. The Chocolate Goat Cheese icecream IS the best icecream I have…"
"…Great service - many flavors. The salted caramel is great!…"
"…The first thing I noticed was the cleanliness, and the politeness of the staff.. After that the positives just kept coming. the knowledge that they al…"
"…I have worked at Frodty Boy now for four years, and every year things just get better. The customers are great, we know them by name, and we even have…"
"…I find this frozen custard almost addictive ! The Flavors of the day means I can have a new flavor every day .…"
"…wonderful unique flavors; quaint shop; awesome staff! A favorite for my family.…"
"…the location is not too far from indy, like a mini-vacation! Love the country atmosphere & unusual brick work. The food is gourmet, healthy & deliciou…"
"…Today at 12:30 I tried to have lunch at the restaurant. I was there with my mom. There was only 1 waitress and 1 cook. It took the waitress at least 2…"
"…Great ice cream/sherbets. Low prices…"
"…Great ice cream - both soft serve and hand dipped! They even will do a doggie dish for the puppies.…"
"…Best FROZEN CUSTARD and Butter Burgers. Good food - good service - good EVERYTHING!…"
"…I have been going to Jimmie's since I was a little girl. Going to get tangerine with crunch coat after a little league softball game at the park is on…"
"…We love Ritters and the fact that they have a different flavor each day. Plus their round free stading restaurant is so cute and gives it that old fa…"
"…Great Throwback Ice Cream Shop. Good prices, great selection, and awesome service!…"
"…This is the best place for Ice cream. They serve so many different flavors of Blue Bell, plus food, shakes, sundaes, bananana splits, and so much more…"
"…Great, unique ice cream and a very friendly and enthusiastic staff.…"
"…Yummy yummy chocolate treats! The staff is very helpful and always willing to offer suggestions. The truffle flavors are very creative. We buy smal…"
The 2017 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 80,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.