Winner
2009 Winner

1. Mama Carolla's Old Italian

Voters Love

"Mama Carolla's is very special to me and my fiancé. It has always been our first choice for date night and is where my..." via Sarah B.

Find It
1031 E 54th St Indianapolis IN 46220
  • Mama Carolla's Old Italian, Great Meals, Italian, Romantic Restaurant, Mexican, 1031 E 54th St World Map Indianapolis IN 46220
    Nominee for: Italian
    1031 E 54th St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Nominee for: Italian
    317 S College Ave, Downtown Indianapolis, IN
  • Bravo Italian Kitchen, Great Meals, Italian, Romantic Restaurant, 8651 Castle Creek Pkwy E Dr Castleton Indianapolis IN 46250
    Nominee for: Italian
    8651 Castle Creek Pkwy E Dr, Castleton Indianapolis, IN
  • Maggiano's Little Italy, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 3550 E 86th St Indianapolis IN 46240
    Nominee for: Italian
    3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
  • Buca di Beppo, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 35 N Illinois St Indianapolis IN 46204
    Nominee for: Italian
    35 N Illinois St, Wholesale District Indianapolis, IN
  • The Old Spaghetti Factory, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 210 S Meridian St Indianapolis IN 46225
    Nominee for: Italian
    210 S Meridian St, Wholesale District Indianapolis, IN
  • Carrabba's, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 1235 Keystone Way Carmel IN 46032 4690 Southport Crossing Drive Southport IN 46237
    Nominee for: Italian
    Multiple locations
  • Milano Inn, Great Meals, Italian, Traditional American, 231 S College Ave Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46202
    Nominee for: Italian
    231 S College Ave, Downtown Indianapolis, IN
  • Nominee for: Italian
    8028 S. Emerson Ave. , Indianapolis, IN
  • Ambrosia Italian, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 915 E Westfield Blvd Indianapolis IN 46220
    Nominee for: Italian
    915 E Westfield Blvd, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Capri Ristorante, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 2602 Ruth Dr Indianapolis IN 46240
    Nominee for: Italian
    2602 Ruth Dr, Indianapolis, IN
  • Matteo's, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 40 N 9th St Noblesville IN 46060
    12. Matteo's
    Nominee for: Italian
    40 N 9th St, Noblesville, IN
  • Nominee for: Italian
    11699 Fallcreek Rd, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Amalfi Ristorante Italiano, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 1351 W 86th St Indianapolis IN 46260
    Nominee for: Italian
    1351 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
  • Papa Joe's, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 1551 N Green St Brownsburg IN 46112
    Nominee for: Italian
    1551 N Green St, Brownsburg, IN
  • Italian Gardens, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 8336 E. Washington St. Indianapolis IN 46229
    Nominee for: Italian
    8336 E. Washington St., Indianapolis, IN
  • Agio, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 635 Massachusetts Ave Indianapolis IN 46204
    16. Agio
    Nominee for: Italian
    635 Massachusetts Ave, Chatham Arch Indianapolis, IN
  • La Trattoria, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 204 N Madison Ave Greenwood IN 46142
    Nominee for: Italian
    204 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, IN
  • Nominee for: Italian
    758 Main Street, Beech Grove, IN
  • Mangia, Great Meals, Italian, 11594 Westfield Blvd Carmel IN 46032
    20. Mangia
    Nominee for: Italian
    11594 Westfield Blvd, Carmel, IN
  • Amici's, Great Meals Restaurants, Italian, 601 E New York St Indianapolis IN 46224
    20. Amici's
    Nominee for: Italian
    601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN
  • Enrico's Italian Restaurant, , , Hillside Ave E Dr Broad Ripple Indianapolis IN 46220
    Nominee for: Italian
    Hillside Ave E Dr, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Cafe Nora, Great Meals, Italian, 1300 E 86th St Indianapolis IN 46240
    Nominee for: Italian
    1300 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
  • Michaelangelo's, Great Meals Restaurants, Mexican, 550 Westfield Rd Noblesville IN 46060
    Nominee for: Italian
    550 Westfield Rd, Noblesville, IN
  • Stefanos Ristorante, Great Meals, Italian, 11680 Commercial Dr Downtown  Fishers IN 46038
    Nominee for: Italian
    11680 Commercial Dr, Wholesale District Fishers, IN
Contest Overview
  • 94,638
    Total Votes
  • 45,956
    Voters
  • 114
    Winners

The 2009 TheIndyChannel.com A-List awards are based on more than 94,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Indy A-List
Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Auto
Beauty
Cheap Eats
Fashion
Great Meals
Health and Fitness
Nightlife
Pets
Shopping
Specialty Food and Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
St. Patrick's Day Showdown – 2015
Microbrew Madness
Hoosier Pork Tenderloin Showdown
My Sugar Pie Showdown
Indy Pancake Bracket Challenge
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Indy A-List features more than 6,792 businesses competing for title of Indianapolis' best.

Connect with Indy A-List

@IndyAList