Traditional American - Best of 2016

Published May 11, 2016

Who serves the best home-cookin?

2016 Winner

1. The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe

Voters Love

"Wonderful, tasty food every single time. I love the meatloaf and mashed potato and green beans combo. Dad's chicken is..." via Katherine Bull

Find It
5614 E Washington Street Indianapolis IN 46219
  • The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Sandwich Shop, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, New American, 5614 E Washington Street Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
    5614 E Washington Street, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Grays Cafeteria, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 555 S Indiana St Mooresville IN 46158
    555 S Indiana St, Mooresville, IN
  • Hollyhock Hill, Great Meals, Weddings, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, Soul Food, Venue, Wedding Venue, 8110 N College Ave World Map Indianapolis IN 46240
    8110 N College Ave, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Hal's Fabulous Vegas Bar & Grille, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 1133 N State Road 135 Greenwood IN 46142
    1133 N State Road 135, Greenwood, IN
  • Steer-In, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Traditional American, Diner, Burger, Breakfast, Barbecue, 5130 E 10th St Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
    5130 E 10th St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • The Local Eatery and Pub, Great Meals, Nightlife, Traditional American, New American, Neighborhood Bar, 14655 Gray Road Carmel IN 46033
    14655 Gray Road, Carmel, IN
  • 922 Massachusetts Ave, Mass Ave Indianapolis, IN
  • Bonge's Tavern, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 9830 W 280 N Anderson IN 46011
    9830 W 280 N, Anderson, IN
  • 8811 Hardegan St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Pure Eatery, Great Meals, Traditional American, Vegetarian, 1043 Virginia Avenue Fountain Square Indianapolis IN 46203
    1043 Virginia Avenue, Fountain Square Indianapolis, IN
  • BJ's Brewhouse, Great Meals, Nightlife, Traditional American, Beer Selection, 1251 Us-31 North Greenwood IN 46142
    Multiple locations
  • Sahm's Place, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 2411 E 65th St Indianapolis IN 46220
    2411 E 65th St, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Stone Creek Dining Company, Great Meals, New American, Seafood, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, Steakhouse, 13904 Town Center Blvd Noblesville IN 46060
    Multiple locations
  • 832 E Westfield Blvd, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Location
    135 E Main St, Morristown, IN
  • Castleton Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 6010 E 82nd St Indianapolis IN 46250
    6010 E 82nd St, Castleton Indianapolis, IN
  • MCL Restaurant & Bakery, Great Meals, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Traditional American, Bakery, Caterer, 86th St & Township Line Rd / 2370 West 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46260
    Multiple locations
  • Slippery Noodle Inn, Nightlife, Great Meals, Live Music Venue, Traditional American, Trendy Bar, Beer Selection, 372 S Meridian St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225
    372 S Meridian St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • City Barbeque, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Sandwich Shop, Breakfast, Traditional American, Burger, Diner, 7863 U.S. 31 World Map Indianapolis IN 46227
    Multiple locations
  • Ted's Montana Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 14490 Clay Terrace Blvd. Carmel IN 46032 5910 W 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46278
    Multiple locations
  • Charleston's, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 31 E Carmel Dr Carmel IN 46032
    31 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN
  • C.R. Heroes Family Pub, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 10570 E. 96th Street Fishers IN 46037
    10570 E. 96th Street, Fishers, IN
  • Location
    5209 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN
  • Fireside Brewhouse, Great Meals, Nightlife, Weddings, Traditional American, Beer Selection, Live Music Venue, Venue, Steakhouse, Neighborhood Bar, 997 E County Line Rd Greenwood IN 46143
    997 E County Line Rd, Greenwood, IN
  • Monon Food Company, Great Meals, Traditional American, 6420 Cornell Ave Broad Ripple Indianapolis IN 46220
    6420 Cornell Ave, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
Contest Overview
  • 100,246
    Total Votes
  • 47,312
  • 157

The 2016 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 100,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Indy A-List
Arts and Entertainment
Beauty and Wellness
Cheap Eats
Great Meals
Home and Garden
Specialty Food and Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
St. Patrick's Day Showdown – 2015
Microbrew Madness
Hoosier Pork Tenderloin Showdown
My Sugar Pie Showdown
Indy Pancake Bracket Challenge
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The Indy A-List features more than 6,266 businesses competing for title of Indianapolis' best.

Connect with Indy A-List