Traditional American - Best of 2016

Published May 11, 2016

Who serves the best home-cookin?

Winner
2016 Winner

1. The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe

Voters Love

"Wonderful, tasty food every single time. I love the meatloaf and mashed potato and green beans combo. Dad's chicken is..." via Katherine Bull

Find It
5614 E Washington Street Indianapolis IN 46219
  • The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Sandwich Shop, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, New American, 5614 E Washington Street Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
    5614 E Washington Street, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Grays Cafeteria, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 555 S Indiana St Mooresville IN 46158
    555 S Indiana St, Mooresville, IN
  • Hollyhock Hill, Great Meals, Weddings, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, Soul Food, Venue, Wedding Venue, 8110 N College Ave World Map Indianapolis IN 46240
    8110 N College Ave, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Hal's Fabulous Vegas Bar & Grille, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 1133 N State Road 135 Greenwood IN 46142
    1133 N State Road 135, Greenwood, IN
  • Steer-In, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Traditional American, Diner, Burger, Breakfast, Barbecue, 5130 E 10th St Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
    5130 E 10th St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • The Local Eatery and Pub, Great Meals, Nightlife, Traditional American, New American, Neighborhood Bar, 14655 Gray Road Carmel IN 46033
    14655 Gray Road, Carmel, IN
  • 922 Massachusetts Ave, Mass Ave Indianapolis, IN
  • Bonge's Tavern, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 9830 W 280 N Anderson IN 46011
    9830 W 280 N, Anderson, IN
  • 8811 Hardegan St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • Pure Eatery, Great Meals, Traditional American, Vegetarian, 1043 Virginia Avenue Fountain Square Indianapolis IN 46203
    1043 Virginia Avenue, Fountain Square Indianapolis, IN
  • BJ's Brewhouse, Great Meals, Nightlife, Traditional American, Beer Selection, 1251 Us-31 North Greenwood IN 46142
    Multiple locations
  • Sahm's Place, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 2411 E 65th St Indianapolis IN 46220
    2411 E 65th St, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Stone Creek Dining Company, Great Meals, New American, Seafood, Traditional American, Romantic Restaurant, Steakhouse, 13904 Town Center Blvd Noblesville IN 46060
    Multiple locations
  • 832 E Westfield Blvd, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Location
    135 E Main St, Morristown, IN
  • Castleton Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 6010 E 82nd St Indianapolis IN 46250
    6010 E 82nd St, Castleton Indianapolis, IN
  • MCL Restaurant & Bakery, Great Meals, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Traditional American, Bakery, Caterer, 86th St & Township Line Rd / 2370 West 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46260
    Multiple locations
  • Slippery Noodle Inn, Nightlife, Great Meals, Live Music Venue, Traditional American, Trendy Bar, Beer Selection, 372 S Meridian St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225
    372 S Meridian St, World Map Indianapolis, IN
  • City Barbeque, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Sandwich Shop, Breakfast, Traditional American, Burger, Diner, 7863 U.S. 31 World Map Indianapolis IN 46227
    Multiple locations
  • Ted's Montana Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 14490 Clay Terrace Blvd. Carmel IN 46032 5910 W 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46278
    Multiple locations
  • Charleston's, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 31 E Carmel Dr Carmel IN 46032
    31 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN
  • C.R. Heroes Family Pub, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 10570 E. 96th Street Fishers IN 46037
    10570 E. 96th Street, Fishers, IN
  • Location
    5209 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN
  • Monon Food Company, Great Meals, Traditional American, 6420 Cornell Ave Broad Ripple Indianapolis IN 46220
    6420 Cornell Ave, Broad Ripple Indianapolis, IN
  • Fireside Brewhouse, Great Meals, Nightlife, Weddings, Traditional American, Beer Selection, Live Music Venue, Venue, Steakhouse, Neighborhood Bar, 997 E County Line Rd Greenwood IN 46143
    997 E County Line Rd, Greenwood, IN
Contest Overview
  • 100,246
    Total Votes
  • 47,312
    Voters
  • 157
    Winners

The 2016 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 100,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Indy A-List
Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Auto
Beauty and Wellness
Cheap Eats
Fashion
Fitness
Great Meals
Home and Garden
Nightlife
Pets
Shopping
Specialty Food and Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
St. Patrick's Day Showdown – 2015
Microbrew Madness
Hoosier Pork Tenderloin Showdown
My Sugar Pie Showdown
Indy Pancake Bracket Challenge
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Indy A-List features more than 6,266 businesses competing for title of Indianapolis' best.

Connect with Indy A-List

@IndyAList