Seriously delicious!!! I had trouble deciding between two burgers. The Liberty Bell , a burger slathered in a cheese sauce, sautéed bell peppers and onions topped with melted provolone, actually surprised I didn't get this burger. I decided on the Mac Daddy. Amazingly delicious!! The patty was not overwhelmingly huge. Just big enough. Topped with dripping cheesy macaroni and cheese and dusted with bacon crumbles. All of this was held together with a soft, fresh flavorful pretzel bun. The dark juices ran cascaded down to my elbows and covered my palms. The flavor of the perfectly medium cooked burger was intense. If I was a cartoon my eyes would have rolled back in my head and been replaced by slots from a slot machine with pictures of burgers on it. Then I would have shook my head, my eyes would have came back, and I would have enthusiastically taken another gigantic bite. The bun stuck to the roof of my mouth and the burger and cheese splashed over my tongue blasting my mouth with flavor. I will be going back and You gotta go! You gotta go real soon!
Vote: BEST Burger
The 2016 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 100,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.