My Sugar Pie Showdown

Who will be your sugar pie?

Welcome to the Indy A-List's My Sugar Pie Showdown! Here's how it works: 16 nominees will face off i

… show more
Round 1 Ended
Round 2 Ended
Semis & Finals Ended
Round 2 Ended
Round 1 Ended
  • 8,013 Total Votes
  • 1 Winner

Rnd 1

Voting in Round 1 is over.
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052 Parky's Smokehouse
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
Wick’s Pies, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 100 N Cherry St Winchester IN 47394
Mrs. Wick’s Pies Winchester 55.0%
Locally Grown Gardens, Specialty Food and Drink, Gourmet Grocery, 1050 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Locally Grown Gardens Indianapolis 45.0%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
Turner's Cocktail & Cuisine at the Canterbury Hotel, Great Meals, New American, 123 S Illinois St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225
Turner's Cocktail & Cuisine Wholesale District 30.1%
Grays Cafeteria, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 555 S Indiana St Mooresville IN 46158
Gray Brothers Cafeteria Mooresville 69.9%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
Barking Dog Cafe Indianapolis 57.2%
Keystone Deli Indianapolis 42.8%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
Concannon’s Bakery, Café and Coffee Bar, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 620 N Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47305
Concannon's Pastry Shop Muncie 39.4%
Dufour's in Irvington, Cheap Eats, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Breakfast, Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Caterer, Venue, 5648 E Washington St Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
Dufour's in Irvington Irvington 60.6%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
My Sugar Pie, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, Zionsville, 40 E Pine St, Zionsville IN 46077
My Sugar Pie Zionsville 54.2%
Shapiro's Delicatessen, Cheap Eats, Specialty Food and Drink, Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Hot Dog, Diner, Pizza, 808 S Meridian St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225
Shapiro's Delicatessen Downtown 45.8%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
MCL Restaurant & Bakery, Great Meals, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Traditional American, Bakery, Caterer, 86th St & Township Line Rd / 2370 West 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46260
MCL Restaurant & Bakery Multiple Locations 43.6%
Nick's Kitchen, Great Meals, New American, 506 N Jefferson St Huntington IN 46750
Nick's Kitchen Huntington 56.4%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
The Attic and Coffee Mill Cafe, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 631 W Main St Madison IN 47250
The Attic and Coffee Mill Cafe Madison 34.3%
Lisa’s Pie Shop, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, US-31 Atlanta IN 46031
Lisa’s Pie Shop Atlanta 65.7%
View this match
Round 1
Feb 26 - Mar 1
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052
Parky's Smokehouse Lebanon 53.3%
Maxine's Chicken & Waffles, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Wings, Soul Food, 132 N East St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Maxine's Chicken & Waffles Downtown 46.7%
View this match

Rnd 2

Voting in Round 2 is over.
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052 Parky's Smokehouse
Round 2
Mar 1 - Mar 4
Wick’s Pies, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 100 N Cherry St Winchester IN 47394
Mrs. Wick’s Pies Winchester 53.8%
Grays Cafeteria, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 555 S Indiana St Mooresville IN 46158
Gray Brothers Cafeteria Mooresville 46.2%
View this match
Round 2
Mar 1 - Mar 4
Barking Dog Cafe Indianapolis 50.3%
Dufour's in Irvington, Cheap Eats, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Breakfast, Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Caterer, Venue, 5648 E Washington St Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219
Dufour's in Irvington Irvington 49.7%
View this match
Round 2
Mar 1 - Mar 4
My Sugar Pie, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, Zionsville, 40 E Pine St, Zionsville IN 46077
My Sugar Pie Zionsville 49.8%
Nick's Kitchen, Great Meals, New American, 506 N Jefferson St Huntington IN 46750
Nick's Kitchen Huntington 50.2%
View this match
Round 2
Mar 1 - Mar 4
Lisa’s Pie Shop, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, US-31 Atlanta IN 46031
Lisa’s Pie Shop Atlanta 48.0%
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052
Parky's Smokehouse Lebanon 52.0%
View this match

Rnd 3

Voting in Semi-Finals is over.
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052 Parky's Smokehouse
Semi-Finals
Mar 4 - Mar 7
Wick’s Pies, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 100 N Cherry St Winchester IN 47394
Mrs. Wick’s Pies Winchester 68.1%
Barking Dog Cafe Indianapolis 31.9%
View this match
Semi-Finals
Mar 4 - Mar 7
Nick's Kitchen, Great Meals, New American, 506 N Jefferson St Huntington IN 46750
Nick's Kitchen Huntington 45.4%
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052
Parky's Smokehouse Lebanon 54.6%
View this match

Rnd 4

Voting in Final Round is over.
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052 Parky's Smokehouse
Final Round
Mar 7 - Mar 9
Wick’s Pies, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 100 N Cherry St Winchester IN 47394
Mrs. Wick’s Pies Winchester 19.5%
Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052
Parky's Smokehouse Lebanon 80.5%
View this match

Bracket Nominees

  • Turner's Cocktail & Cuisine at the Canterbury Hotel, Great Meals, New American, 123 S Illinois St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225 Turner's Cocktail & Cuisine Wholesale District
  • The Attic and Coffee Mill Cafe, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 631 W Main St Madison IN 47250 The Attic and Coffee Mill Cafe Madison
  • Barking Dog Cafe Indianapolis "GREAT burger! Crispy and thin and twice as big as the bun! Soooooo delicious!! The fries came with a kalamata olive..."
  • Nick's Kitchen, Great Meals, New American, 506 N Jefferson St Huntington IN 46750 Nick's Kitchen Huntington
  • Wick’s Pies, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 100 N Cherry St Winchester IN 47394 Mrs. Wick’s Pies Winchester
  • Locally Grown Gardens, Specialty Food and Drink, Gourmet Grocery, 1050 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220 Locally Grown Gardens Indianapolis "Incredible baked goods, a variety of specialty soft drinks, and the best local produce all year! Who needs anything..."
  • Keystone Deli Indianapolis "mom and pop, bring cash,......maybe she takes plastic now...?"
  • Concannon’s Bakery, Café and Coffee Bar, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, 620 N Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47305 Concannon's Pastry Shop Muncie "Their doughnuts are worth the drive!"
  • My Sugar Pie, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, Zionsville, 40 E Pine St, Zionsville IN 46077 My Sugar Pie Zionsville "The best PIES EVER!!! I cannot wait for the Thanksgiving Cheesecake Pie!!! UNREAL! Amazing bakery, an amazing..."
  • Lisa’s Pie Shop, Specialty Food and Drink, Bakery, US-31 Atlanta IN 46031 Lisa’s Pie Shop Atlanta "this bakery does not accept credit or debit... one day I walked in with no cash and they were so kind to let me just..."
  • Grays Cafeteria, Great Meals Restaurants, Traditional American, 555 S Indiana St Mooresville IN 46158 Gray Brothers Cafeteria Mooresville "The food is like homemade and always taste delicious, and the pies are hard to pass up even if you are on a diet. To..."
  • Parky's Smokehouse, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Barbecue, Steakhouse, Diner, Burger, Wings, Seafood, 2479 N Lebanon St Lebanon IN 46052 Parky's Smokehouse Lebanon "Great service, good food and an owner who is there and cares. Not many good places in Lebanon. This is the place for..."
  • Maxine's Chicken & Waffles, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Wings, Soul Food, 132 N East St, Indianapolis, IN 46204 Maxine's Chicken & Waffles Downtown "The Best Catfish In Town!!!! I am Sold!!!! Maxine's is Winning hands down!!!!!"
  • MCL Restaurant & Bakery, Great Meals, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Traditional American, Bakery, Caterer, 86th St & Township Line Rd / 2370 West 86th St. Indianapolis IN 46260 MCL Restaurant & Bakery Multiple Locations "A mainstay for the middle class. Confidence in quality and affordability...something America is struggling to preserve..."
  • Shapiro's Delicatessen, Cheap Eats, Specialty Food and Drink, Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Hot Dog, Diner, Pizza, 808 S Meridian St Downtown  Indianapolis IN 46225 Shapiro's Delicatessen Downtown "i went here once to try something new and i wish i didn't. ong i thought i was in the hood i expected for my car to be..."
  • Dufour's in Irvington, Cheap Eats, Specialty Food and Drink, Weddings, Breakfast, Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Caterer, Venue, 5648 E Washington St Irvington Indianapolis IN 46219 Dufour's in Irvington Irvington "This place is totally overated...Its like eating at a Flea Market. I drove there from Fishers and will not do that..."
Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Auto
Beauty and Wellness
Cheap Eats
Fashion
Fitness
Great Meals
Home and Garden
Nightlife
Pets
Shopping
Specialty Food and Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Microbrew Madness
Hoosier Pork Tenderloin Showdown
My Sugar Pie Showdown
Indy Pancake Bracket Challenge
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Indy A-List features more than 5,689 businesses competing for title of Indianapolis' best.

Connect with Indy A-List

@IndyAList