Nominee for Best Traditional American
Great servers. Go there regularly on Sunday's after church
Vote: BEST Traditional American
Everything is great about the Castleton Grill! Best kept secret in Indianapolis!
This is my FAVORITE local restaurant in all of Indianapolis! Castleton Grill is definitely the BEST Traditional American Restaurant! Great Food, Awesome Staff & Beautiful Design both inside and out!
Fish & Chips with the jalepeno sauce - awesome
The orchard fries and brussel sprouts!!
Love "Dog Night" on Mondays! Always a go to place whenever we just want to break away. Great menu
Try the prime rib specials before 6pm Reasonable price and fabulous prime rib
Heard they have good burgers, never tried them but that is what I hear.
I'm not sure what Traditional American food means. McDonald's? Wendy's maybe? It all kind of blows. That being said, I've had a few good meals here. The blackened fish sandwich is very nice with the pit beans.
The 2017 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 80,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Garden Center ⋅
Best Doggie Daycare ⋅
Best Wedding Hair and Make-Up ⋅
Best FroYo ⋅
Best Neighborhood Bar
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.