Mama Carolla's Old Italian

Awards

• See Italian Winners   2012 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 52)  
• See Italian Winners   2011 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 47)  
• See Romantic Restaurant Winners   2011 BEST Romantic Restaurant Finalist (#5 out of 20)  
• See Italian Winners   2010 BEST Italian Finalist (#4 out of 32)  
• See Italian Winners   2009 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 29)  
• See Italian Winners   2008 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 27)  

71 Tips from Voters

Lavonda H. on August 17, 2012

YUM!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Marcella S. on August 15, 2012

Great atmosphere

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Lori C. on August 14, 2012

No one has better Lasagna than Mama Carolla's

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

MickeyMouseMellie on August 14, 2012

Everything is fresh, home made, and the servers are always so attentive to your needs. I have never been disappointed in anything I have eaten there! SIMPLY THE BEST!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Heather A. on August 14, 2012

Great place for a date or for a large group. Best Italian in Indy, hands down!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

turtlenate on August 14, 2012

Yum

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Rory V. on August 14, 2012

Love your food. Keep up the good work.

Vote: BEST Romantic Restaurant

Like 0 Likes

Mary ann Y. on August 11, 2012

A family special occasion place.

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Margaret K. on August 10, 2012

cute little place :)

Vote: BEST Romantic Restaurant

Like 0 Likes

Margaret K. on August 10, 2012

awesome food :) great atmosphere

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes