Mama Carolla's Old Italian

Awards

• See Italian Winners   2012 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 52)  
• See Italian Winners   2011 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 47)  
• See Romantic Restaurant Winners   2011 BEST Romantic Restaurant Finalist (#5 out of 20)  
• See Italian Winners   2010 BEST Italian Finalist (#4 out of 32)  
• See Italian Winners   2009 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 29)  
• See Italian Winners   2008 BEST Italian Winner (#1 out of 27)  

71 Tips from Voters

Twoartguys on August 3, 2011

one of the best places to eat in the city

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

gracie56 on July 27, 2011

BEST FOOD AND ATMOSPHERE

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Melanie T. on July 27, 2011

Totally awesome!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Leah P. on July 27, 2011

Melts in your mouth, it's so good.

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Lisa P. on July 24, 2011

This place, hands down, is numero uno! Their bruschetta is to die for! Each dish is wonderful! When we want Italian, this is where we go!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

jleighty on July 23, 2011

Outstanding Italian, best I have been to in any city that didn't reside in Italy.

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

legalease on July 22, 2011

Fantastic food and great service!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Stephen S. on July 21, 2011

The best Italian food in Indianapolis. The wedding soup is a staple.

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

Victoria H. on July 19, 2011

Best kept secret in Indy!!!!! Awesome food & atmosphere!!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes

DEW5245 on June 27, 2011

House wine is excellent!

Vote: BEST Italian

Like 0 Likes