Ranked #1 of 49 for Best Italian
Ranked #1 of 23 for Best Romantic Restaurant
Vote: BEST Italian
Best scallops I've ever had!
Everything is great about Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant ... the homemade bread and soups, all the pasta and sauces, the desserts, the wine, the atmosphere, the staff, the location, etc.
My favorite place!
Took my girl here for Valentine's Day this year. It was perfect. A great experience. I would recommend Mama Carolla's to everyone!
Best pasta....and a great place for celebrations. Love this atmosphere here!
We love the quaintess of the place, the garden dining, and of course the wonderful food....
Best place in Broad Ripple for Italian~delicious!
The 2017 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 80,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Beer Selection ⋅
Best Brewpub ⋅
Best Shoes ⋅
Best Acupuncture ⋅
Best Wedding Flowers
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.