Every Vote Counts! Sign Up to get a ballot and help choose the BEST of the BEST

VOTE NOW! Nominated for 1 category

0 YOUR VOTES

150+ TOTAL VOTES

17 DAYS LEFT

Mama Carolla's Old Italian

Nominated for: BEST Italian

Mama Carolla's Old Italian 1031 E 54th St Indianapolis IN (317) 259-9412

Come see why many call this the best Italian in Indianapolis!

Is this your business? Manage this page

Awards

See all 7 awards

95 Tips from Voters

William Reed on July 2, 2012

Magnifico!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

saeber on July 1, 2012

Amazing Italian

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Rex S. on June 30, 2012

Love the food, patio and owners. Great place at reasonable prices. They were in SoBro before it was know as SoBro.....so ahead or their time !

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Catharine M. on June 29, 2012

you MUST eat their cheesy garlic bread...YUM!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Varlie S. on June 29, 2012

iT MELTO IN YO MOUTHO

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Colleen P. on June 28, 2012

I don't eat Italian in Indy often but when I do, I go here. It is the closest to home (South Jersey).

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

charles i. letbetter on June 27, 2012

Having traveled all over Italy, I'm familiar with real, homemade Italian food, and Mama Carolla's is it!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

allyson sipe on June 27, 2012

Incredible dining experience. Wonderful staff!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Beth C. on June 26, 2012

Never disappoints!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

JMReid1220 on June 25, 2012

Great food and great atmosphere!

Vote: BEST Italian

0 Likes

Load More Tips

Popular Nominees: Italian

See More »
A2Z Italian Cafe, Restaurants, New American, 4705 E 96th St Indianapolis IN 46240

A2Z Cafe A2Z Cafe Indianapolis, IN

BEST Italian

37th
< 20
17

Napoli Villa Napoli Villa Beech Grove, IN

BEST Italian

1st
200+
182

Pizzology Pizzology Carmel, IN

BEST Italian

33rd
< 20
37

Augustino's Italian Restaurant Augustino's Italian Restaurant Indianapolis, IN

BEST Italian

5th
60+
157

Voters also love

Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Auto
Beauty and Wellness
Cheap Eats
Fashion
Fitness
Great Meals
Home and Garden
Nightlife
Pets
Shopping
Specialty Food and Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Past Winners
Top Voters
Microbrew Madness
Hoosier Pork Tenderloin Showdown
My Sugar Pie Showdown
Indy Pancake Bracket Challenge
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Indy A-List is a contest featuring more than 5,119 local businesses competing to be named best. YOUR votes determine the outcome. Voting ends Sunday, August 17th

Connect with Indy A-List