Ranked #1 of 51 for Best Italian
Definitely the best overall! I love their outside seating in the garden and the overall intimate atmosphere. Great location, amazing food!
Vote: BEST Italian
hear its great.. need to get down there.
Best Mussels in town!!
Love the food, patio and owners. Great place at reasonable prices. They were in SoBro before it was know as SoBro.....so ahead or their time !
you MUST eat their cheesy garlic bread...YUM!
iT MELTO IN YO MOUTHO
I don't eat Italian in Indy often but when I do, I go here. It is the closest to home (South Jersey).
Having traveled all over Italy, I'm familiar with real, homemade Italian food, and Mama Carolla's is it!
The 2014 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 103,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Hair Salon ⋅
Best Personal Trainers ⋅
Best Boarding ⋅
Best Motorcycle Shop ⋅
Best Interior Design
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.