Mo's Irish Pub always has a good band playing on the weekend. It's a fun atmosphere and offer a wide range of beers on tap. If you aren't into the band playing, there is also seating closer to the bar area which still gives you some privacy to have a conversation. They also have a nice outdoor seating area if you want to enjoy a warm summer night.
Vote: BEST Neighborhood Bar
2017 Indy A-List: Important Dates