Ranked #14 of 60 for Best Bakery
My favorite pie!!!
Vote: BEST Bakery
You will not possibly be disappointed - ABSOLUTELY the BEST, and the pies come in lovely glass plates, so classy!!!!
Best pie ever- to equal flavor, I would have been in the kitchen forever. it is much easier for My Sugar Pie to do!
If you haven't tried Kelly's pie, you're missing the best pie in Indiana.
The best pies, the best people!
Love these high quality pie. Yum
Amazing!!! The best!!!
The Dutch Apple is to die for!!!!
Best pies no doubt
crust is awesome
The 2016 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 100,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Hair Color ⋅
Best Gay and Lesbian Bar ⋅
Best Wine Bar ⋅
Best Eyewear ⋅
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.