Ranked #9 of 26 for Best Steakhouse
fantastic - everything!
Vote: BEST Steakhouse
Awesome wine list!
Large portion of salmon with fantastic sauce served over yearling potatoes and baby spinach!
Perfect date place for romantic evening
Vote: BEST Romantic Restaurant
Scrumptious food, lovely ambiance, superb service, best of the best!
it is very unusual to find a locally owned steakhouse of this caliber. We try to go every year for our anniversary, and the food & service make us feel really special!! Never a bad meal there.
Make reservations for your special occasions. The service can't be beat!
Dim lighting means you'll need your reading glasses, but it makes the succulant steak dinner feel more romantic.
I eat at a lot of places, but if I want steak in this city, there isn't a place better than Peterson's. I've never had a bad one there even when the economy was bad, the owner and chef did not sacrifice on the quality of the food. EXCELLENT!
It is a delusion that St. Elmo's is good. I think it may have been good at one time but clearly not now. Peterson's is the best restaurant in all of Indy.
The 2017 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 80,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Handyman ⋅
Best Bridesmaid Dresses ⋅
Best Wings ⋅
Best Doggie Daycare ⋅
Best Dance Studio
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.