Ranked #10 of 35 for Best Ice Cream Shop
A bit pricey - but oh my, the gelato tastes like Roma!
Vote: BEST Ice Cream Shop
Always the best far above the rest!
It doesn't get any better than Pinocchio's!!
I've had the original Pinocchio's on Sanibel Island, FL at the recommendation of Mandy. It's so nice to have one closer. I always try a sample of something new but always end up with my fave...Dirty Sand Dollar. Awesome owners and staff!
It's the Ice Cream that Jesus would eat, if he ate ice cream!
The staff makes it the most amazing!
The service here is wonderful, and the ice cream is DELICIOUS!
Love this place!!!!!!!!
Pinocchio's has the friendliest staff. Their ice cream and Gelato are delicious and offer unique flavors!
The 2017 Indy A-List awards are based on more than 80,000 votes from local Indianapolis-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Pet Sitting ⋅
Best Doggie Daycare ⋅
Best Golf Course ⋅
Best Coffee Shop ⋅
Connect with Indy A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.